While FHA mortgage insurance relief could improve affordability, eliminating premiums at 80 perxent loan-to-value risks weakening the insurance fund, making loan seasoning a potentially safer alternative; meanwhile, historically low refinancing activity is squeezing mortgage originators’ profitability, with fewer than 1 percent of borrowers holding refinance incentives and 2027 Agency MBS issuance projected at $1.1 trillion gross and $200–$225 billion net amid persistently high mortgage rates and subdued home price appreciation.
Robbie interviews Sandler Law Group’s Peter Idziak on how election outcomes and growing AI use may affect mortgage lenders’ regulatory and operational risks. Expect limited federal regulatory change, with more enforcement variation at the state level as some states gain Democratic attorneys general and appointive authority shifts. State attorneys general may focus on AI decisioning and alleged corruption, including RESPA Section 8, loan officer compensation, and anti-steering issues.
And longer-dated Treasuries have rallied on weakening housing data and strong auction demand, but persistent inflation, resilient economic growth, and increasingly hawkish Fed expectations (including the possibility of a 50-basis point December hike) leave interest rates biased higher, with future yield movements hinging on the balance between inflation risks and deteriorating market conditions.
Thank you to by Experian. From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Welcome to The Chrisman Commentary, your go-to daily mortgage news podcast, where industry insights meet expert analysis. Hosted by Robbie Chrisman, this podcast delivers the latest updates on mortgage rates, capital markets, and the forces shaping the housing finance landscape. Whether you're a seasoned professional or just looking to stay informed, you'll get clear, concise breakdowns of market trends and economic shifts that impact the mortgage world.
Presented by
Experian — From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Robbie ChrismanWelcome to the Chrisman Commentary, Daily Mortgage News Podcast. I'm your host, Robbie Chrisman. Topics on today's episode include look at some of the technological malfunctions we've had recently, mortgage insurance and delinquencies, and my interview with Sandler Law Group, Peter Idziak, on how election outcomes and growing AI use may affect mortgage lenders' regulatory and operational risks. Here, take a listen to a little preview. Counterparty risk from vendors in the age of AI. Obviously, that could be an hour-long discussion, but when it comes to the way that regulations are trending or your own crystal ball that you want to pull out, lenders are ultimately responsible for decisioning or things that were correct. Despite, you know, you can try and put the blame on a vendor partner, but at the end of the day, it's lenders that are likely going to be responsible. Peter IdziakYou know, for your counterparties, for your for your investors against your regulators, you're the responsible party. And part of that is, you know, for regulators, like you are the regulated entity. For investors, you know, you're the one that's wrapping and warranting the loan that you're selling to them. So it is difficult. I will say that I think there is a sort of a broad-based understanding that this is a new technology, that there's great value in it, and there's there's risk, and that it's moving very quickly. So, in my experience talking to regulators that I've talked to at the state level, they're experimenting with AI as well. So everybody knows this is kind of new. There will be issues. You know, there seems to be sort of in the wider economy, like a tolerance for you know AI, you know, hacks. You know, if a human being did it, they'd they'd be uh you know arrested and in prison. But if it was Claude's model that just sort of you know got out of its sandbox and did what it was uh supposed to do, everyone sort of goes, oh well, you know, that's that's sort of the cost of doing business. And it's it's sort of the same with us. But Robbie Chrismanhold on, where where does the buck ultimate where's the buck ultimately going going to stop? It has to stop somewhere. Peter IdziakUltimately, I mean, you know, look, between you, between the regulator and the lender, between the investor and the lender, the buck stops with the lender. But you know, that's why your contracts with your vendors are important, because to the extent that you have any kind of like monetary penalty, fine, buyback, demand, or or fee paid to it for a loan defect, like that you can offload that risk onto your vendor. So, I mean, at the end of the day, where does the buck stop? It's with the vendor that's used the AI and it's ultimately with like the AI company. But that's where you get into counterparty risk, right? And that's why you need kind of a seasoned and established vendor, because there are like we've seen over the last couple of years with a lot of the fintechs that have gotten into the mortgage space that don't really understand the regulatory climate, that you know, it's great if you get hit with like a million-dollar consent order and then you go and turn to your vendor and say, hey, you know, under our agreement, I've got a claim against you, and they say, Well, we have no money. Uh so I mean, the lender, I think, you know, you manage the best you can, but you recognize that for your business, the buck will stop with you. Robbie ChrismanYou can't get blood from a stone. I've learned that in the legal world in a variety of ways. From lenders and landlords to employees and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian. You can learn more at Experian.com. Lenders continue to explore and carry out artificial intelligence initiatives to, in theory, leverage their employee skills. Just for the record, in case any banks are having trouble restoring account balances after these outages, my Wells Fargo checking account had exactly $164,790,392 in it, and my Amex credit card balance was zero dollars. Just putting that out there so there's no confusion when everything comes back online. Oh, and I paid off my mortgage right before the system went down. Check your records. For grounded tech answers for lenders, today at 10 a.m. Pacific, 1 p.m. Eastern, is the third Chrisman demo day where a surety, rake check, blue sage, acre, lender price, Kotura, Vesta, true, and secure insight do 10 minute presentations on their latest and greatest. Tune in from your Barcalounger. Eight companies, 10 minutes each, one connected pipeline. You can register at CrispinCommentary.com or just go to our YouTube page to watch it live at 10 a.m. Pacific noon here in Texas. 30-year mortgage rates don't track 30-year treasury security rates, but it's still good to generally know what's happening out there on the yield curve. Longer dated treasuries rallied for a third consecutive day yesterday as sharply weaker building permits down 7.4% month over month to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of $1.295 million, and solid demand at the 20-year Treasury auction outweighed initial selling pressure from Fed Governor Waller's comments, supporting consideration of the 50 basis point of December rate hike. Shorter term yields edged higher amid shifting monetary policy expectations. Before the rally, November's rise in treasury yields was driven primarily by higher real yields rather than inflation expectations, reflecting stronger growth expectations and a more hawkish Federal Reserve outlook. Continued confidence in the Fed's commitment to price stability has kept inflation expectations and risk premium relatively contained. However, nominal yields could quickly increase and investors begin questioning the Fed's ability or willingness to contain inflation. Markets are increasingly anticipating another round of monetary tightening, with investors expecting both the Fed and European Central Bank to deliver quarter-point rate increases at their next respective meetings that would push borrowing costs to their highest levels in over a year, adding pressure on businesses carrying floating rate debt. Weakness in technology shares, questions about the payoff from AI spending, and demand for safer assets are limiting the rise in Treasury yields, leaving interest rates dependent on whether the economy remains strong and inflation persists, or an AI-driven market correction triggers tighter financial conditions and weaker employment. Although the Fed held rates steady in October, the decision was a close call. FOMC minutes released yesterday revealed a growing consensus for further rate hikes, as persistent, broad-based inflation and resilient economic growth keep policymakers concerned. Nearly all FOMC members favor additional tightening, and some are open to a 50 basis point move if inflation fails to moderate. For today's interview, I wanted to welcome back to the show Sandler Law Group's Peter Idziak to talk about how election outcomes and growing AI use may affect mortgage lenders' regulatory and operational risks. He's partner in charge of Sandler Law Group, where he leads the firm's residential mortgage practice and guides the day-to-day management of its legal and compliance professionals. He directs the firm's client service activities, supervisors and mentors its attorneys, and oversees the legal review, disclosure, and compliance work that mortgage lenders in Texas and nationwide need to originate and fund loans accurately and on time. You and I were both in Austin for the Texas Housing Summit, and there was a compliance session. My big takeaway was state associations are now hiring ex CFPB enforcement attorneys. And so that just creates a myriad of complexities out there in terms of you know, if I'm licensed in 50 states trying to figure out how to deal with all 50 states and remain compliant. But let's let's run down the list here. First one I mentioned was was obviously the midterms blue wave, blue NAMI, whatever you want to call it. Uh Texas is an especially poignant example. Blue for the first time in 30 plus years in the Senate, first Hispanic female Robbie Chrismangovernor. Uh Tallerico, we're going, we're going Frico for Talarica, whatever they say down there. You're more versed in it than I am. But when it comes to regulation, and more at the national level than Texas, although Texas is a microcosm. Thoughts on what the midterms mean for mortgage regulation? Peter IdziakAt the federal level, I don't think much changes uh in federal regulation because you still have a Republican president and therefore Republican, you know, executive agency heads. We may see a little bit more action, uh, presuming Brian Johnson gets confirmed as uh head of the CFPB, you know, as we might talk about a little bit later. There are some uh you know, housing priorities in Trump's executive orders that do require uh executive agency action. But really, the the change is going to be at the state level. One of the big things I think that we don't always think about in our industry, we we focus on regulators, but the attorney generals. There are something like six uh or five or six states, including Texas, Georgia, Kansas, and perhaps Ohio, where you're seeing a uh flip from a Republican attorney general to a Democratic attorney general. Now, not only can these AGs enforce state consumer uh financial protection law, but they can also uh enforce many of the federal laws. And one of the key areas that I think that we're gonna see is, well, I should say two, one is AI adoption that's been not mortgage specific, but this idea of automated decisioning that whether I'm approved or denied for housing, credit, what have you, based on uh you know, an algorithm essentially, is something that's worrisome and was flagged in several of these uh AG candidates' campaigns. The other is, and it was a voter concern, is corruption. And in the mortgage industry, you know, we have RESPA section eight, we have anti-kickback provision, we have LOComp and anti-steering. So you may see some increased action at the state level. Um, it's not so much on the radar right now, it wasn't a campaign issue, but for AGs that are looking to fight quote unquote corruption uh from the mortgage perspective, that may be something to watch. Um, as far as regulations, you know, Texas is sort of a microcosm in one way that we did have the blue wave, but our regulators are interesting because they're appointed by the uh Texas Finance Commission who has staggered terms. So you won't see much change there. But there are other states where you are going to have governors that have the authority to appoint regulators that share their democratic worldview. So to the extent that you know the focus for your compliance department looking forward, you know, where do I look? I think it's gonna be at the state level. And and I would flag, you know, uh AI adoption, which is sort of on everybody's radar, but the thing that might fly under the radar a little bit uh until it pops out is um it's corruption respite section eight, you know. And we find that state AGs kind of move in packs. Whenever one of them sort of finds a hook, especially something that gets them press, then the others follow. Robbie ChrismanYou brought up AI. So let's talk about AI. Obviously, everybody I think is using it on some level at this Robbie Chrismanpoint. Robbie ChrismanBorrowers are using it, investors are using it, regulators, as you alluded, are also using it. How does all of Robbie Chrismanthis Robbie Chrismanaffect lenders? It's almost Robbie Chrismanlike Robbie Chrismanlenders are being Robbie Chrismanhit from Robbie Chrismanevery side Robbie Chrismanby Robbie Chrismantheir Robbie Chrismancounterparties Robbie Chrismanusing AI. It seems like it's a lot to keep Robbie Chrismanup with. Peter IdziakYeah, I mean, I you know, you're right on your first point. You know, even if you don't think you're using AI, you probably are in some fashion. Some of the tools that you use in your day-to-day, uh, big thing would be vendors. You are getting hit by all sides. And I think a lot of the focus initially for lenders and for really anybody has been how can I use AI to improve my business, to make it more efficient, to reduce risk. But everybody else has a seat at that table, too. And we are seeing borrowers use AI more, both in uh the origination process, you know, they they will go to Claude and input all their financial information. And you know, Claude will tell them that they qualify for something. They will take your loan estimate and they will run it through AI. Beyond that, you know, on the complaint side, many of my clients are seeing clearly AI generated complaints that you cannot just dismiss out of hand, even if they are sort of overbroad. There is uh you know, some way under RESPA to sort of avoid those. But you have to you have to engage with the entire complaint. And you go from something where you have this sort of general in the past, you know, my LO told me this, and you know, that was wrong, to eight pages citing every like federal and state statute that may or may not apply. We've seen it in in foreclosure defenses too. You know, in the past, for a borrower, uh, they might not have the ability to afford their own lawyer. So they would just, you know, sort of acquiesce to the foreclosure process. But now I can just go to Claude or Chat and put in the complaint, uh, the foreclosure action, and it'll tighten me up a defense. And if for a lender, for someone foreclosing, you know, it raises your cost of foreclosure. You have to engage with it. And regulators are seeing this as well. You know, the CFPB has sort of revamped their consumer uh complaint portal to make it harder for AI generated complaints to be put in. Uh, and then on the investor side, in the past, sort of your your human capital you had limited the number of loans that you've maybe able to uh to excuse me to audit uh prior to purchase. But now with AI tools, you know, much higher percentage of those are getting audited. So if you're a lender that maybe you know has had some operational issues with defects or clearing conditions, in the past, it's just sort of the limit of human attention and resources might allow you to still sort of like sneak through in a sense. But now we're seeing investors that are flagging upwards of probably reviewing 50%, if not more, of some of the loans that are being purchased by them. And we're seeing that at the GSE level as well. So this initial thought that, well, AI will just make you know everything more efficient for me. It'll it'll reduce the cost of originating a loan, it may still be true, but it's raising costs elsewhere. And as a someone in a decision-making position at a lender, you have to think through too how your employees, how your LOs are using AI. One of the things that we caution as attorneys to lenders is you know, be careful with where you send our communications. You know, if you are just putting into the uh off-the-shelf Claude, there is at least one court out there that has said that you've waived attorney client privilege. And beyond that, yeah, you know, uh I've heard this complaint uh from several, uh, not just in the mortgage industry, but but professionals, that now when we give our advice to a client, they go and they put it into Claude and ask Claude if it's correct. And you know, AI systems are probabilistic. So they generally try to create text and responses based on what the most likely next word basically is after the word that's been used before. So they're really good at at the general, at the average, at the median, but they're really bad at edge cases. And a lot of times the reason that I'm getting asked the question is because it's an edge case. And I find myself more and more sort of debating with the client's Claude response as to why I'm right or why that answer is incomplete. And our practice is mostly fee for service, but we do build by the hour. And I've actually found that on some of these, you know, in the past that I might have spent 30 minutes an hour answering your question now with the back and forth and responding to Claude, that it's taking me twice as long. And that you know, that gets passed on to the client. So I'd I'd caution lenders on that too, because it's it's not always the panacea. And you know, our our firm, we we uh we draft a lot of documents and I have documents that I know that I'm really familiar with. And if you come to me and you want sort of a customized version of that, I know my documents inside and out, and I can do it for you fairly you know quickly. But if you ask Claude to generate like a construction loan agreement and send it to me and ask me to review it, one, it's not gonna be that great. Uh they're not the AI LLM sort of just not there yet. Uh, maybe in two years, you know, I'll be out of a job. But for right now, at least I'm still necessary. But it it's it's it's a back and forth that again, it takes longer. At the end of the day, overall, clients are seeing benefits to AI adoption. They are seeing efficiencies, but you know, costs are rising elsewhere. And the big thing is in this is that it's moving so fast that you have your processes and procedures in place to manage your AI usage, your vendors' AI usage today, but it can change in six months dramatically. And keeping pace with all those changes is very difficult because regulators, investors, you know, they are requiring lenders to have an AI inventory of how you're using AI, how your vendors are using AI. And in the past, you know, maybe once a year was sufficient for that. And it was manageable. But now, you know, every aspect of your business, every vendor is using AI in some capacity. And keeping up with that and managing that and insurance being used in a compliant manner is becoming very burdensome. Robbie ChrismanSo when when I say Peter, what is the state of fair lending regulation at the federal and state level post-midterms? Is it you know, gird your loins out there? The CFPB is coming roaring back. I almost think that the bigger concern for lenders, at least nationwide lenders, is having to deal with all these different state by state regulations and remaining compliant. Peter IdziakRight. You know, I mean, we've always had states, slip blue states that have kind of gone their own way and been, you know, in my view, sort of overly, you know, uh involved in this area. But states have limited resources. And so when they feel that the federal government is sort of uh, you know, across an issue uh like reg B disparate impact in the past, you know, you see sort of less uh attention being paid by the states. You know, why duplicate the federal effort when I can use my resources somewhere else? But we do have the CFPB's uh Reg B rule uh that came out and was effective in July that you know remove disparate impact, uh, but that still exists in many state laws. So, you know, if you're a lender that's across several states, to your point, you can't just say, well, at the federal level, you unknown 18:33 know, Peter Idziakdisparate impact uh is no longer a reg B component. So I don't have to worry about it because you know you still do. And in a sense, too, you've seen states that basically, like New Jersey, implemented some disparate impact rules recently that the MBA is sued to block, where they see the federal government sort of retreating, they decide, well, it's time for us to get involved now. And so for lenders, depending on where you're lending, obviously, it can actually be a little bit more difficult for you because to your point, you do now have this patchwork of different regulators you have to talk to, of different standards you have to comply with. And if you're lending in 50 states, sometimes it's okay, well, you know, what's the most restrictive law that I have to comply with? And then I will, you know, my processes and procedures will be implemented to meet that. I would say that uh we'll see what happens in New Jersey uh with the NBA's lawsuit against that. So far, there's been some indication that states are going to seek to increase their enforcement in this action, but don't expect any change at the federal level. You may have hearings because you do now have, presumably, Maxine Waters is going to be chair of uh financial services in the House, and then Elizabeth Warren, Senate Banking. Uh, and this uh for Warren especially has been a pet issue over the years. But beyond just the hearings and making noise, like not much at the federal level. I it'll be interesting to see what we get with the Democratic AGs, whether they really look into this. A lot of them are fairly moderate. So even though you know, Blue Wave and some of the more liberal members that are trying to claim this as like, you know, a the rise of populism or something, um, like what we've seen in Texas, I think is replicated in other states, is it's a more, you know, we're moderates, like we're not here to throw out the baby with the bathwater. We, the Democrats, feel that the pendulum has swung too far, you know, in favor of moneyed interests, let's say. So we're gonna bring it back, but not all the way. I think they recognize that um from their public statements that if you are in a state that has been, you know, governed by Republicans that has been economically successful, that you don't need to rock the boat too much on that. So it's you know, long story short, it's it's gonna be a patchwork. Even within the political party, it'll be up to sort of individual AGs how much they care about this issue and how much they want to push on it. I think where you'll probably see it is not in your traditional sense, but in the AI, you know, underwriting and decisioning. Now, in in our industry, maybe mortgage lending, maybe not so problematic because a lot of our underwriting is based on Fannie Freddy, like D U L P. But in consumer lending in the larger sense, you may see some actions. You know, we did see one in in Massachusetts, I think, two years ago, and that was in um student loans. So you may see a COA enforcement disparate impact in that. And the other, the other area too is AI-generated advertising. You know, that's one area where whenever I go to these conferences and I hear the LOs talk about how they're using AI to maximize their business and their consumer contact. You know, a lot of that's like consumer advertising. And if you have your AI just churning out ad after ad, is it compliant? Like who's reviewing that? And their ability to create content is you know sort of outstripping your compliance department's ability to review it. Robbie ChrismanHope you're enjoying the new gig over there at Sandler. And uh looking forward to talking to you again soon. Peter IdziakYeah, sounds good. Robbie ChrismanThere's been some chatter out there about reducing the upfront or annual mortgage insurance premiums, that's MIP, to improve mortgage housing affordability. However, eliminating MIP once borrowers reach 80% loan-to-value could weaken financial positions by reducing future premium revenue, particularly since approximately 52 52% of the $1.45 trillion in FHA Ginny May 2 30-year mortgage balances could qualify. Unlike conventional borrowers, FHA borrowers generally have lower credit scores, higher debt-to-income ratios, and greater default risk. While home equity can quickly erode during housing downturns, and the funds capital ratio relies heavily on home price appreciation assumptions. Some are saying that a more prudent approach would be to base MIP relief on loan seasoning rather than LTV, as FHA delinquency and foreclosure risk decline substantially after ten years, allowing policymakers to improve affordability without prematurely compromising the insurance fund's financial stability. Mortgage prepayment speeds for both conventional and Ginnie Mae 30-year loans have fallen to historic lows, suggesting refinance activity has likely bottomed, as higher mortgage rates have virtually eliminated borrowers' refinancing incentives. Fewer than 1% of conventional FHA and VA borrowers are currently in the money. The rapid disappearance of refinancing opportunities has significantly weakened mortgage lenders' production pipelines and revenue potential, contributing to industry profitability challenges. That was a rough MBA third quarter profitability report, huh? As refinance volume has largely dried up. 2027 agency MBS issuance is projected at approximately $1.1 trillion gross and $200 to $225 billion net, assuming mortgage rates remain elevated at 7.25 to 7.5%, and home price appreciation remains limited. Today's economic calendar kicked off with initial jobless claims and at $203,000, about unchange from last week, and continuing claims and at $1.763 million, a slight uptick from last week. Later today brings the November Philadelphia Fed Survey, KC Fed Manufacturing Index, a 10-year tips auction, and Fed remarks from Jefferson, Goolsbee, Barkin, and Bar. We begin the day with agency MBS prices, little change from Wednesday's close, the two-year yielding 4.81, and the 10-year yielding 5.08 after closing yesterday at 5.07%. Let's wrap up with a joke and some housekeeping. A turkey walks into a bar and the bartender says, What are you? Turkey replies, I'm a wild turkey. The bartender chuckles and replies, Hey, we have a drink named after you. Wild Turkey Incredulous asks, You have a drink named Kevin? Thanks again to Experian for sponsoring this week's podcasts. From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Join 80,000+ mortgage professionals who start their day with Chrisman Commentary.
By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Chrisman LLC, 1930 Village Center Circle, #3-3932, Las Vegas, NV, 89134, https://www.chrismancommentary.com/. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact