Mortgage lenders experienced a sharp decline in profitability in the third quarter of 2026, posting an average $30 pre-tax loss per loan amid rising production costs, lower loan volumes, and declining revenues, while stronger servicing income provided some relief and increased pressure for cost-cutting measures heading into 2027.
Robbie interviews LexisNexis Risk Solutions' Kim Sutherland on the growing financial impact of AI-driven fraud and bot activity, and adaptive fraud prevention that balances stronger identity verification and risk detection with minimal customer friction and churn.
And despite resilient job growth and continued economic expansion, persistent inflation is eroding household purchasing power and weakening consumer spending, while equity volatility fuels safe-haven demand and high borrowing and construction costs continue to depress housing sentiment and purchase activity, highlighting a growing disconnect between headline economic strength and mounting financial pressures on American households.
Thank you to by Experian. From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Welcome to The Chrisman Commentary, your go-to daily mortgage news podcast, where industry insights meet expert analysis. Hosted by Robbie Chrisman, this podcast delivers the latest updates on mortgage rates, capital markets, and the forces shaping the housing finance landscape. Whether you're a seasoned professional or just looking to stay informed, you'll get clear, concise breakdowns of market trends and economic shifts that impact the mortgage world.
Presented by
Experian — From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Robbie ChrismanWelcome to the Chrisman Commentary, Daily Mortgage News Podcast. I'm your host, Robbie Chrisman. Topics on today's episode include government in lending, where we're seeing IMB's bottom lines turn red, and my interview with LexisNexis Risk Solutions’ Kim Sutherland, to discuss the growing financial impact of AI-driven fraud and bot activity and adaptive fraud prevention that balances stronger identity verification and risk detection with minimal customer friction and churn. Here, take a listen to a little preview. We obviously have seen some wonky things lately with the Microsoft Outlook outage, the FAA grounding of flights. There's stuff going on with banks to open the week this week. Just your thoughts on where we are in terms of this new reality that the Robbie ChrismanGenAI tools can be used for bad. And it seems like a lot of very critical infrastructure systems out there are not necessarily prepared for this reality that we're in. Kim SutherlandWe've definitely seen some very uh surprising and challenging outages, but I don't know if any of these things are related. So this reminds me so much about the importance of analytic models and ignoring the anomalous behavior. We need to be able to make effective decisions based off of looking at patterns, understanding behavioral trends and expectations. And that is where automated models make a difference. That's also where being able to have adaptive approaches make a big difference as well. So static fraud models are not effective. Being able to address all of the types of changes that we're seeing, um, some of them that, you know, we're not sure again why it's happening, but being able to have adaptive approaches to managing your business is gonna be a very important approach in the future and now. And so being able to leverage AI-enhanced capabilities will allow us to be able to get into that mode because fraud is constantly changing. Um, and so we've got to be able to have solutions that can help as well. And that's also gonna mean educating employees and making them more comfortable with the implementation of AI-based solutions and um knowing how to incorporate them into their daily processes. Robbie ChrismanFrom lenders and landlords to employees and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian. You can learn more at Experian.com. The Mortgage Bankers Association reported that independent mortgage banks and mortgage subsidiaries of depository banks reported an average pre-tax net production loss of $30 per loan they originated in the third quarter of 2026, compared to a net production profit of $973 per loan in the second quarter of 2026. Staff reductions and other cost-cutting measures may accelerate the rest of this year and in the first quarter of 2027, said Marina Walsh, CMB, MBA's Vice President and Head of Industry Analysis. Quote, average pre-tax net production income reached its lowest level for a third quarter since 2023. The results are particularly disappointing given that the third quarter has historically been the strongest quarter of the year. As mortgage rates increased over the summer, the industry struggled with lower production volume and escalating production costs. Average first mortgage loan balances declined for the second consecutive quarter, contributing to a decline of approximately $325 per loan in production revenues. Mortgage servicing income held up better than production per loan, net servicing financial income more than doubled in the third quarter as prepayments slowed and the valuation of mortgage servicing rights increased. Combining both production and servicing operations, 59% of mortgage companies generated a profit in the third quarter, but at the lowest level since the first quarter of 2025. Without mortgage servicing operations, only 44% of companies would have been profitable. The average pre-tax production loss was four basis points in the third quarter of 2026, compared to profit of 25 basis points in the second quarter of 2026. The average quarterly pre-tax production profit from the third quarter of 2008 to the most recent quarter is 38 basis points. Total production revenue, that's fee income, net secondary marketing income, and warehouse spread decreased to 331 basis points in the third quarter, down from 333 basis points in the second quarter. On a per loan basis, production revenues decreased to $11,585 per loan in the third quarter, down from $11,909 per loan in the second quarter. Total loan production expenses, that's commissions, compensation, occupancy, equipment, and other production expenses and corporate allocations, increased to 335 basis points in the third quarter of 2026 from 308 basis points in the second quarter. Per loan costs increased to $11,615 per loan in the third quarter. For the mortgage industry as a whole, MBA estimates the purchase share was at 73% in the third quarter of 2026. Finally, servicing net financial income for the third quarter without annualizing was $195 per loan serviced, up from $80 per loan serviced in the second quarter. Servicing operating income, which excludes MSR amortization, gains and losses in the valuation of servicing rights instead of hedging gains, losses, and gains and losses on the bulk sale of MSRs, was $85 per loan serviced in the third quarter, unchanged from the second quarter. For today's interview, I wanted to welcome to the show LexisNexis Risk Solutions’ Kim Sutherland, talk about the growing financial impact of AI-driven fraud and bot activity and adaptive fraud prevention that balances stronger identity verification and risk detection with minimal customer friction and churn. She's global head of fraud and identity at LexisNexis Risk Solutions, where she leads the America's commercial market strategy for consumer fraud analytics, identity verification, authentication, and fraud investigations. Robbie ChrismanI think a good place to start might be kind of like a State of the Union on fraud in the financial services and lending community. And obviously, this is a podcast for residential mortgage industry professionals, but your thoughts on fraud overall. And I know that's so wide net that I just cast, but it seems like it's always omnipresent. The fraudsters are getting better with AI, you know, the technology out there, you know, on the mortgage company side of things when it comes to wire fraud or title fraud continues to improve, but there's always going to be bad actors. Give us a little bit on the uh overall landscape. Kim SutherlandSure. The cost of fraud does continue to climb for financial services and lending firms. Uh, we've seen this uh occur since the inception of our True Cost of Fraud report, which started in 2009, where we started to ask companies how much does one dollar of fraud actually cost your business? And it is not one dollar, obviously. That effort of being able to track that along with the evolving nature of technology is really what makes it such a challenge for businesses to be able to detect and um prevent fraud. Robbie ChrismanThoughts on how we are trending in terms of capabilities out there to prevent fraud versus the bad actors. What are we seeing in terms of the evolution of fraud schemes that are being deployed? Any more info you can give us would be great. Kim SutherlandYeah, definitely scams, something that everyone can relate to. Um you see them in your emails, text messages. It's a pervasive effort that impacts nearly everyone. So scams, bot activity, and AI-generated fraud are what's driving most of the losses for companies. Um, scams alone account for almost a third of fraud losses. And the biggest challenge with scams is that most firms only reimburse about a third of them. Malicious bots are something that we we track annually as well, and uh they make up about um 14 to 15 percent of transactions in the US and Canada. So we know that scripted attacks are ones that are uh leaned on by a lot of fraudulent actors, um, and AI-generated techniques make it even easier, and that's now contributing to about 20% of fraud losses in the U.S. Robbie ChrismanWhat are we seeing in terms of increased defense capabilities or preventative measures, things companies are doing well, best practices. Maybe the the best defense is a good offense, but when it when it comes to preventing fraud or mitigating fraud risk, uh what are what are some best practices out there? Kim SutherlandIt really is true that you know the best way to reduce fraud is to stop it at the door. And businesses have done a great job of trying to deploy layered fraud defenses. That is an extremely effective approach. There's been a lot of focus on trying to deal with identity verification, which you'd think that it'd be something that people can easily do now, but that is not what we see. Uh, being able to easily and accurately verify name, address, date of birth (DOB), email, phone are still areas that companies have spent a lot of time investing in, but they're also starting to shift to looking at more of the digital risk and biometric authentication. So where businesses are planning to invest more in the next 24 months, biometric authentication, digital risk assessment. And I'll say that's because the majority of transactions now are coming in digitally, either on their website or via a mobile app. Um, so you're definitely seeing that activity and behavioral intelligence. So not just the device is risky, but how the individual is interacting with the device or interacting with the web page. So those three areas, we're seeing a lot of opportunity for invest interest and investment. And then the same thing with leveraging credentials, uh, digital credentials. So going beyond just the leveraging of driver's licenses and passports to even wanting to accept a verified digital credential. So those types of activities are really uh where organizations are expanding their investments in more modern and AI-enhanced prevention. Robbie ChrismanOne of the things I found fascinating about the report was that fraud controls carry a growth cost, as in fraud prevention strategies are increasing customer churn. And so I think it begs the question: what's the proper balance of trying to maintain growth out there with your customer base or your products or your top line volume, with also putting proper controls in place? I'm one failed two-factor authentication away from throwing my phone out the window because I can't figure out my password and I'm frustrated. I mean, what's what's the proper balance here? Kim SutherlandWell, I think that what's really interesting to me about the uh findings is that the respondents to um our True Cost of Fraud survey understood that reducing fraud is not about only minimizing the fraud loss itself, but it's directly tied to improving customer trust and loyalty as well as giving a better customer experience, right? Trying to reduce friction. So businesses definitely see that investing in strong fraud prevention strategies helps increase or reduce their uh customer churn or increase their customer um loyalty. Robbie ChrismanSo I'm down here in the great state of Texas, and they they have these electronic billboards and they say X amount of deaths this year on the road, let's get to zero. And I don't mean to be morbid, but is a realistic goal out there that companies can have zero fraud in a in a perfect utopian world, is fraud always inevitable? And so it's about finding the best ways to mitigate it once it happens. How should companies be approaching the way that they view their exposure to fraud? Kim SutherlandYou can absolutely have zero fraud. That means that you almost don't let anybody in the process. So trying to find that balance of reducing fraud while not impacting good customers is really, really important in that process. The area that I think most businesses focus on is how do you at least reduce that cost of fraud? So this year we saw that the cost of fraud for $1 loss is $5.47. So 5x what the actual loss is, is the impact to a business. If that's the case, really trying to find ways to get that number down is critical for businesses. And it is not just adding additional fraud solutions. It's really ensuring that the way that the solutions work together is the most effective, that it actually does reduce operational costs for the business, and that it helps support the onboarding of new customers so you can grow that relationship. Robbie ChrismanYou are the global head of fraud and identity at LexisNexis Risk Solutions. What do you like so much about your job? Kim SutherlandSo this is actually my 20th year with LexisNexis Risk Solutions. And I think what I uh really appreciate about working at LexisNexis Risk Solutions is that we try to help make the world a safer place. We believe that using data for good can really help solve some of the most critical problems in the world. And so I love that we make an impact. I love that what we tried to solve and from a fraud standpoint 10 years ago is so different than today. And so fraud continues to evolve, our solutions continue to evolve, the marketplace overall continues to evolve, and we're here, you know, to continue to um improve that process for our customers. Robbie ChrismanObviously, I'd be remiss if I didn't talk about AI a little bit. My understanding, it's creating a layered approach to fraud. Prevention. Can you explain just how now that AI has entered the proverbial chat, things are changing, companies are utilizing it to their advantage? Kim SutherlandYeah, so AI has, you know, a very important place in making things much more efficient and effective. Um, all of us are probably using some elements of AI uh every day in our processes, whether it be making it easier to take notes or automating processes. And when we see the use of AI agents in the workplace, we are seeing that same thing for personal use. That adoption of agentic AI is now becoming something that is not just meant to make things easier and better, it makes fraudsters easier to commit their fraud attacks. So where we're trying to help companies is first in the detection of AI agents. It's very important to know when you're working with a human, with a bot, or with an agent. And then trying to go down further into the path of saying that all agentic traffic is not bad traffic. Again, consumers are trying to make their life easier as well. So right now, it's an effort where most businesses are attempting to block agentic traffic because it's hard to understand the intent. Our goal right now is to start with identification that can lead down the path to understanding the intent of an agent as well. Robbie ChrismanFor people out there listening to this interview today that are obviously concerned about this impacting them or their organization, anything that you feel like they can do, steps they can take now, things that are worth implementing into their daily routines or their overall business practices that can make a tangible difference? Kim SutherlandYeah, one of the other findings within our true cost of fraud study was just how important it is to identify those manual processes that can improve through automation. And so fraud prevention maturity by looking at automated fraud programs, they consistently outperform the manual ones. I would recommend to any business, you know, better understand if there is an opportunity to further automate processes and then leveraging a combination of digital identity verification and behavioral aspects to really address a more effective fraud strategy. Robbie ChrismanExcellent insights. I really appreciate the time for people out there looking for the survey. You can find it at LexisNexis Risk Solutions. Kim, I really appreciate the time. Hope to have you back on soon. Kim SutherlandThank you so much. I appreciate your time. Robbie ChrismanMortgage volatility continues as equity weakness fuels safe haven demand. Despite continued economic growth, persistent inflation is eroding household purchasing power, with real wages declining 0.6% year over year through September, while PCE inflation remains elevated at 3.6%, and October gasoline prices surged 37% from a year earlier. Household finances are showing signs of strain as real disposable income fell 0.3% in September, and inflation-adjusted consumer spending was nearly flat, suggesting consumers are struggling to keep pace with rising costs. The economic growth we hear of is increasingly driven by business investment and other spending rather than stronger household purchasing power, creating a growing disconnect between positive headline economic performance and the financial pressures experienced by everyday Americans. Fortunately, the U.S. labor market remains resilient, with average monthly job growth of 137,000, comfortably exceeding the estimated breakeven pace of just 20,000 to 35,000 jobs, given the Federal Reserve or giving the Federal Reserve room to maintain restrictive monetary policy, despite a meaningful slowdown in hiring. Unfortunately, U.S. home builder confidence has fallen to a 14-year low, with the headline index and all major components declining as high mortgage rates, persistent inflation, elevated construction costs, labor shortages, and hesitant buyers weigh on the housing market. Approximately 2.5 million purchase loans are expected to be closed in 2026, 26% below the 3.4 million annual average from 2016 to 2019, and that is despite relatively stable dollar-based purchase MBS issuance. Evidence of just how much inflation-adjusted housing activity remains significantly depressed. Today's economic calendar kicked off with mortgage applications from MBA, which fell 2.3% for the week ending November 13th, as rising treasury yields and renewed expectations of Federal Reserve rate hikes pushed the 30-year fixed mortgage rate to a three-week high of 7.35%. Higher borrowing costs weighed on both purchase and refinance activity, with purchase applications down 18% year over year, and refinance applications down 54% year over year, signaling continued pressure on housing demand. We've also received October housing starts, which came in at $1.309 million, up 9.9% month over month, and building permits, which came in at 1.295 million, down 7.4% month over month. Later today brings October pending home sales, weekly crude oil inventories, the October FOMC minutes, and a treasury auction of $16 billion of 20-year bonds. We begin the day with agency MBS prices nearly unchanged from Tuesday's close, the two-year yielding 4.80, and the 10-year yielding 5.10 after closing yesterday at 5.10%. Let's wrap up with a joke and some housekeeping. It's the day before Thanksgiving. And the butcher's just locking up when a man begins pounding on the front door. Please let me in, says the man desperately. I forgot to buy a turkey and my wife will kill me if I don't come home with one. Okay, says the butcher. Let me see what I have left. He goes into the freezer and discovers that there's one last scrawny turkey left. He brings it out to show the man. That one's too skinny. What else you got? says the man. The butcher takes the bird back into the freezer and waits a few minutes and brings the same turkey back out to the man. Oh no, says the man. That doesn't look any better. You better give me both of them. Thanks again to Experian for sponsoring this week's podcasts. From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Today's Guest
K
Kimberly Sutherland
Global Head of Fraud & Identity at LexisNexis Risk Solutions
Join 80,000+ mortgage professionals who start their day with Chrisman Commentary.
By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Chrisman LLC, 1930 Village Center Circle, #3-3932, Las Vegas, NV, 89134, https://www.chrismancommentary.com/. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact