FICO’s January 1 pricing transition raises significant competition, cost, and implementation concerns, as complex subscription requirements, inconsistent bureau participation, and unresolved system arrangements could leave thousands of lenders without essential FICO scores, disrupting mortgage lending and borrowers’ access to credit.
Robbie interviews author Richard Vague on historical inflation cycles, and how politicians can improve mortgage affordability over time, and create a more favorable economic environment despite an anticipated stock market correction and potential near-term rate increases.
And persistent inflation, rising oil prices, and hawkish Federal Reserve signals have driven Treasury yields higher and increased expectations for a December rate hike, keeping borrowing and mortgage rates elevated while markets await further economic data and signs of meaningful disinflation.
Thank you to by Experian. From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Welcome to The Chrisman Commentary, your go-to daily mortgage news podcast, where industry insights meet expert analysis. Hosted by Robbie Chrisman, this podcast delivers the latest updates on mortgage rates, capital markets, and the forces shaping the housing finance landscape. Whether you're a seasoned professional or just looking to stay informed, you'll get clear, concise breakdowns of market trends and economic shifts that impact the mortgage world.
Presented by
Experian — From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Robbie ChrismanWelcome to the Chrisman Commentary, Daily Mortgage News podcast. I'm your host, Robbie Chrisman. Topics on today's episode include More outages? Really? We have some big news on FICO's January 1 deadline that we're breaking here on Chrisman, and my interview with author Richard Vague on historical inflation cycles and how politicians can improve mortgage affordability over time and create a more favorable economic environment, despite an anticipated stock market correction and potential near-term rate increases. Here, take a listen to a little preview.If I'm a mortgage loan officer and I'm talking to a client or a prospective client about what the heck's going onoutthere, what am I telling them? How do I make heads or tails? How am I advising them when it comes to the biggest purchase in their life when thingsseem so unaffordable right now? Richard VagueTo proceed. I mean, you know, then nobody's going to like to hear this, but I think folks need to proceed cautiously. You can enter a mortgage and refinance when things get better. I don't think things are going to get materially worse. And by materially, I mean I don't think rates are going to go up more by more than 50 to 100 basis points more on the long end. And then I think they're going to come back down to earth. And, you know, you hear what we're starting to see is a lot of articles. Read one this morning saying, you know, 7% yield on a treasury security is better than owning a stock. So I think the money's going to start shifting. That'll provide a little bit of relief for that into the market. So I would counsel, you know, patience and caution. You know, some folks have to buy homes. I know that's how these folks make their living here. Uh, but I see brighter days out a year, two or three from now. So, you know, we just need to somehow carry on. Robbie ChrismanFrom lenders and landlords to employees and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian. You can learn more at Experian.com. There have been too many failures of systems in the last few days, and now the large banks, that's Chase, Wells, Truist, and others, were hit with an outage. A sprawling malware attack reportedly has hit Zoom. Artificial intelligence and tech problems are not only impacting lender clients and companies, but also the overall financial system. Yep. Its impact is widespread. Artificial intelligence emerged as the leading financial stability concern in the Federal Reserve's latest financial stability report, cited by 87% of survey respondents, up from 50% in May. Respondents highlighted risks tied to elevated equity valuations, cybersecurity, and complex AI financing arrangements. The report also flagged rising treasury yields and elevated hedge fund leverage while describing the banking system as resilient. Does it give you the willies when you shop for socks or say socks out loud, and the next day an ad pops up for socks? It's going to become worse. Apple opens the door to a nightmare world of always listening tech. Their new upcoming ambient audio recording features set a risky precedent in normalizing intrusive surveillance. Switching gears slightly, a reader raised a concern that deserves broader industry attention. FICO's January 1 pricing transition could leave some lenders without the scores their businesses depend on. The conversation is focused on pricing, but the more urgent question is whether the industry can implement these arrangements in time. And what happens to lenders and borrowers if it cannot. FICO's preferred program offers $10 wholesale pricing per bureau, provided lenders commit to obtaining FICO scores on every covered credit report. That raises serious competition and antitrust questions. How meaningful is the choice to use a competing score if retaining preferred pricing requires purchasing FICO? Describing enrollment as voluntary does not resolve the concern when the alternatives present substantial financial and operational challenges. The original subscription alternative requires an annual commitment billed monthly. In a letter from Equifax to a lender, the terms describe a 12-month obligation regardless of whether scores are requested in any particular month. The commitment also survives termination of the lender's service agreement, with the remaining balance becoming due. The same letter explains that lenders using additional resellers may owe duplicate subscription payments, with FICO subsequently rebating the additional amounts. That introduces collection, reconciliation, and cash flow complications for lenders using multiple providers. A newer monthly subscription reportedly resets the commitment each month, but costs more than the annual option. Lenders would therefore pay a premium for flexibility while the underlying implementation challenges remain unresolved. Shorter billing commitment does not make the system supporting it ready. FICO's annual subscription table names 4,771 lenders. It also includes a limited volume category for unlisted lenders and another category requiring FICO to determine pricing and included volume case by case. This requires lender-specific arrangements to be identified, communicated, implemented, and maintained across multiple organizations. That complexity is the missing piece in much of the discussion. Under the process described by industry participants, credit reporting agencies must obtain lender authorizations, submit those elections to FICO, and have the corresponding information communicated to the bureaus. The appropriate arrangements must then be applied across lender accounts, credit reporting platforms, score delivery systems, and royalty billing. December leaves little room for unresolved questions, corrections, and testing. Bureau participation adds another concern. Experian reportedly does not intend to offer subscription pricing. If that remains its position, how does a lender implement a consistent subscription strategy across a three-bureau report? A pricing option on paper is only useful if the distribution channels needed to deliver it can support it. The largest lenders are likely to be prioritized, but what happens to the thousands of other lenders still waiting for pricing clarification, authorization processing, or system configuration. Without the necessary scores, their ability to obtain GSE pricing and acceptance could be disrupted. Being further down, the implementation queue should not put a lender's ability to conduct business at risk. The potential consequence goes well beyond an incorrect invoice. In a letter from Equifax to a lender, the third option is identified. No FICO score usage after December 31st. The concern is straightforward. As described by industry participants, if the applicable royalty arrangements are not established and correctly implemented, the bureaus will not provide FICO scores. A lender could be willing to pay and still receive reports without those scores because the arrangements governing their delivery remain unresolved. Vantage score may provide an alternative for eligible loans, but acceptance of a model does not mean every lender has tested a path to use it. Technology integrations, underwriting procedures, and investor requirements must all align. Lenders need contingency plans now, but contingency planning should not become an excuse to transfer responsibility for an unworkable transition onto them. Bureaus and credit reporting agencies reportedly have requested extensions. Those requests should be treated as warnings about execution risk. Holding firm on January 1st, without a workable process for every affected lender, would place the consequences of unresolved pricing and distribution arrangements on businesses and consumers who do not control them. That's not the partnership this transition requires. The industry should collectively demand an extension, clear and workable implementation procedures, consistent treatment across distribution channels, and uninterrupted score access while elections and technical issues are resolved. This is no longer simply a debate about the cost of a credit report. It's a question of whether lenders can continue conducting business. The industry needs to take a stand before a pricing deadline becomes a lending disruption. For today's interview, I wanted to welcome to the show author Richard Vague to talk about historical inflation cycles and how politicians can improve mortgage affordability over time and create a more favorable economic environment despite an anticipated stock market correction and potential near-term rate increases. He's an American business person, venture capitalist, and the author who served as Secretary of Banking and Securities of Pennsylvania from 2020 until 2023.Where should we even start? Because I do want to talk market cycles, but maybe your background would be good. You run two credit card banks, you were Pennsylvania's Secretary of Banking and Securities, you're a published author. You probably find your book on Amazon. And so maybe start with your background. What interests you so much about the markets? How'd you get into this? And what continues to keep you so interested today? Richard VagueWell, first of all, thank you for having me on your podcast. You've got a great podcast, and it's a privilege to be here. And you know, I stumbled into banking trying to work my way through the University of Texas way back when. You know, I got a job down the street at a bank, you know, working odd hours to try to pay the tuition, which back in those days was a reasonable amount. But, you know, stayed in banking uh through my career. And if you're in banking, I guess if you're in any business, but certainly in banking, we had to pay a lot of attention. You know, I became CEO after a few years, and your ability to manage your business, to earn the money that your shareholders want and to survive, frankly, is all dependent on uh understanding market cycles, which can, you know, get quite volatile. Robbie ChrismanSomeday on this podcast, I'll tell the story of when I was a student at the University of Texas and worked at the Texas Water Development Board by the Capitol Building one summer, and and they uh they had 89 straight days of 100 plus degrees and no rain that summer in Austin because I was trying to get in, I had to stay to get in-state tuition to lower the cost. So there you go. You and me, not so different. But uh let's let's talk about what we're seeing currently. And there's no way to really put your finger on it because traditional debt assets aren't behaving in normal ways. You could say, hey, well, the the Federal Reserve sucked a bunch of demand from the housing cycle forward, and affordability is at an all-time low. This is to say nothing of how much it costs to put diesel in my truck at this point. When you look at what's going on, is there any precedent for this? Maybe that's where I would like to start this. Richard VagueYeah, I do think there's a precedent, and I think that precedent is uh the oil crisis of uh the 1970s. We started a war in the Middle East, the Strait of Hormuz is closed, oil supplies are significantly constrained, the price of oil has gone to over $100. To me, that is the heart and soul of what we're experiencing right now. And that's very much like what happened in mid-1973, when because of our taking sides with Israel in the Yom Kippur War, Saudi Arabia and the OPEC nations intentionally constrained supplies to punish us. Oil went from $4 a barrel to $12 a barrel almost immediately. And then that was followed up by the Iran revolution in 79, where again we found ourselves at odds with that nation in a very dramatic way. And oil went from $12 to $39 a barrel. So in a period of six years, oil went from $4 to almost $40. And it really hammered the U.S. economy. And what we saw in terms of inflation and rates was almost entirely due to oil. And I think that's largely what we're seeing right now. Robbie ChrismanWell, that led to massive stagflation, which some people might feel that we're heading toward here. There's still a lot of corporate investment and other things going on. There's a lot of strong signals in the economy. Well, we're on the historical precedent. Let's talk about what it led to beyond stagflation. Paul Volcker came in as Fed chair in 79, and he was basically a very unpopular Fed chair. And he enacted these measures that hurt the American consumers at the time, but probably allowed for the American economy to flourish later. And so is that sort of responsibility, for lack of a better term, what we need to get out of these times. And it's obviously not going to be easy. No politician wants to say, cool, I'm gonna make life harder for everyday Americans so there could be a light at the end of the tunnel. Like what in your estimation, if that's the historical precedent, what's it going to take today? Like what are we heading towards today, and how do we how do we get back toward prosperity? Richard VagueWell, I have a bit of a contrarian view on that. In that at that point in time, the issue was a constraint in the supply of oil. And the other factor that was in place at that time was the Richard Nixon's price controls, wage and price controls, which he had put on in 71 to 73 when the U.S. got off the gold standard. And one of the dire consequences of that, that was unanticipated at the time, is you could not charge more than that $4 adjusted slightly for the oil that you pulled out of the ground in the United States. So when prices went up to $12.73 and beyond, all the oil companies took all their activity away from the United States because to drill for oil in the United States, you couldn't make a profit. Oil was at $40 a barrel, and if you drilled in the United States, it would you could only sell it for $4. Doesn't take a genius to know that that doesn't work. So what happened first under Jimmy Carter, who was the great deregulator, if you remember the deregulated telecommunications and the airlines and all these other things. Well, he started the process of deregulating the price of oil at the wellhead. And Ronald Reagan took that up so that early on in Reagan's term, oil was completely deregulated, and drilling in the United States tripled, tripled. And the amount of oil produced in the United States obviously increased greatly. So that's what brought the price of oil down, and that's what led to the benign inflation that really started in about 83, you know, took a while. Everybody adds to that the fact that Volcker took rates up to 20% and, you know, beat the you know what out of the U.S. economy. We had a major recession as a result of that. Of course, you know, if rates are good 20%, that's going to happen. I'm one of those that view that as an unnecessary and harmful adjunct. And in fact, inflation didn't come down until rates had come down 300 or 400 basis points in the early 80s. So it was well after uh Volcker did his things. And I kind of have a similar view now. I don't I think the issues the war and I think the issues of tariffs, I don't see, and you know, I we've done a lot of study around this on all the instances of inflation in the economy uh over 200 or something years. I don't see interest rates as being a determinant. Robbie ChrismanCan we be as reductive as saying when the conflict in the Middle East eases and oil flows resume, and maybe some of these tariffs get knocked off eventually, things will go back to normal. I mean, this is to say nothing of fiscal concerns in the U.S., which a lot of these oil prices they've brought to the fore. Hey, there's $40 trillion of debt. And it's getting more and more expensive for the U.S. government to finance itself, and who knows where that's going to lead. Like I said, there's a lot of factors going on here. Richard VagueYeah, I'm gonna say absolutely, it is as simple as if we went in and, you know, there's nothing simple about resolving the Iran war, but let's pretend for a moment that we could resolve it and that the oil began to flow in the Strait of Hormuz again. We solve that problem and we get rid of the tariffs that are so self-defeating at this point in time. Inflation, which by the way, is still only in the 3-4% range right now, will go down and interest rates will go down. There's a there's a natural corollary there. I want to tell you, we were just looking this at, we were just studying this over the last several weeks. The six instances of inflation that have happened since World War II. 1947, which is the decimation of supplies from World War II, 46 and 47, 1950, which was the Korean War, 1968, which is when we were desperately trying to defend the gold standard, and gold was flowing out of this country faster than we could control it. Our gold reserves were cut in half in the decade of the 60s, and we were bumping up interest rates to try to give folks a reason to not do that. The 70s, when oil increased tenfold in price, and then COVID was the sixth one, in which point in time our supply chains were decimated, and you know, guys weren't going to factories, so supplies uh were short, and we had a brief 15-month period of inflation. So in not one of those periods was government debt-to-GDP increasing. Not one. It was declining in 46, it was declining in 50, it was declining in 68, it was declining in the 70s. So there's there's and and conversely, the great periods of government debt increase, which were the Reagan era, the defense spending, the Obama rescue of the um global financial crisis, and the COVID rescue, in two of those three, inflation came down. So I'm not sure there's an empirical case to be made that government spending is the culprit here. I think war and tariffs are the culprit. Robbie ChrismanWell, which I we people that listen to this podcast, know I'm not political, but if you're talking about those, you can trace it back to Trump. And in for most of his presidency, there was the taco trade, the Trump always chickens out trade. And what's interesting about what's happened with Iran is a lot of these red lines that people a lot smarter than me thought Trump wouldn't cross, and a lot of institutional investors and those on Wall Street, whether that's oil breaching a certain dollar amount per barrel, whether that's the 10-year treasury clearing 5%, so on and so forth, those lines have been breached, and he has not backed off. And so I'm I'm wondering if this is a complete recalibration of what people thought was possible in terms of what how the lengths to which the government would go, but also readjusting expectations once again for this higher for longer rate environment. First inflation was transitory, then it was a transitory, now it's higher for longer, and then now it's well, it's going to be even higher than what higher originally was. And now it's going to be there for a lot. Do we just need to constantly be dynamic in the ways that we're assessing this because there's so much uncertainty abounding? Richard VagueI think your assessment is correct. You know, Trump, we will read many books about this for many years and we'll we'll hear the story. But I think it's reasonable to guess that Trump got just terrible advice. That they dealt with Venezuela in about 48 hours, and they thought they could do that in Iran. And, you know, those are two very different situations. And I think they've done something that, you know, they can't put the toothpaste back in the tube here. There's no easy way. And I, you know, I try to think about this myself. What is the way you could reach some kind of tolerable impasse? And for me for me, the model is the Korean War, which still, by the way, is an ongoing war. It has never been resolved. They just came to an agreement that they would Robbie Chrismanhave a demilitariation zone. Boom, and then on we go. Richard VagueAnd start negotiating, and then they never got back to the negotiating, and things normalized, and we never declared an end to that war. And I'm not sure that you couldn't do something like that in Hormuz, even if it cost you a little money in terms of fees you pay to Iran for traveling the strait. Robbie ChrismanI'm going to ask you point blank then. How do we do our best to get toothpaste back in the tube, if at all possible? If I try and do it, I can get a little in usually, right? Richard VagueYou know, it's going to take somebody besides Trump and Hegseth and those guys, because they clearly don't know how to navigate this. And they, you know, have, you know, I've made many mistakes in my career. And I'm always the worst one, even though I fixed some of my mistakes, just the mortification of having to snare your mistake straight, you know, is makes it all the more difficult. And it usually takes somebody else to come in who doesn't have their ego on the line. I'm not sure that won't have to be the case here. But if somebody was willing to make, you know, if somebody was an adult, realized how profound the implications here and was willing to lose a little face in a negotiation, you could get back to something that resembled normality. Like I said, maybe just declare that we're negotiating, but not really. And the world would somewhat normalize. That's the only path I can see. If we continue to bomb these guys, it's just going to get worse. Robbie ChrismanPart of good diplomatic negotiation is always finding an off-ramp for both parties and a suitable off-ramp. So where do we go from here? At least in the shorter term. Is it near-term pain for long-term gain, is what's been floated out. What's your thought on how things move from here, knowing that this is a podcast on residential mortgages, and there's a lot of people out there that are going, I can't afford anything right now. Richard VagueI actually think that we're going to have a stock market correction. There have been a lot of stock market. There's been like seven stock market corrections since the global financial crisis. So stock market corrections are far short of being the end of the world. They last a year or two. Guys that are leveraged on the stock market get their lose their shirts. But even in the 2001 Internet 1.0 crisis, GDP actually didn't decline. So I actually think we're going to have a correction. It's going to be largely a stock correction rather than a GDP reduction. Robbie ChrismanAnd Richard Vagueinterest rates will moderate at that time because the Fed's going to have to come in and ease circumstances. That's what the that's what the Fed has to do in situations like that. So if we can just not let things get out of control, we can kind of live through this correction. I think the interest rate environment on the other side of this is going to be more beneficial. Robbie ChrismanYeah. Well, it'll be interesting because the Fed has obviously placed a priority on inflation, more so than employment when you think about their dual mandate. And so if tariffs and oil haven't resolved themselves and there's a stock market correction, the Fed's going to go, well, inflation's still high. Why would we ease? And that creates a whole nother convolution of factors. Richard VagueWell, maybe maybe you're right. But normally in those periods, prices back off, you know, because uh demand softens. So it'd be unusual for the for there not to be at least some room for rate reduction. And by the way, you know, we've studied central banks, including the Federal Reserve, back to the 1400s in Barcelona. Central banks were not created to deal with employment and inflation. They were created to rescue economies in calamity. That's why the Fed came about in 1913 after the big 1907 crisis. The first and most important job of the central bank is to be the lender of last resort. And they clearly played that role in 2008. Politicians piled on this idea that, you know, the Fed could and should control inflation and employment. And it's, you know, it doesn't ring true to me that a quarter-point move in the interest rates one way or the other really have that much effect on either inflation or employment. Robbie ChrismanRichard, I really appreciate the time. Great to get an opinion like yours. And uh hopefully this is the start of uh us having uh some great dialogues on this podcast. So thank you. Richard VagueWell, listen, you got a great podcast. Uh you do a fabulous job, and it's an honor to be part of it. Robbie ChrismanWith Fed Chair Warsh scaling back on telling the public what the Federal Reserve's Open Market Committee is doing and thinking, U.S. Treasury traders are watching the U.S. Federal Reserve speeches, and the minutes of October's policy meeting, after stronger than expected inflation and hawkish comments, drove a sharp rise in bond yields last week. U.S. two-year yields climbed as much as 37 basis points, and the 10-year yield exceeded 5%, while interest rate futures priced in a quarter-point increase in December and approximately 90 basis points of cumulative tightening by September of 2027. Those higher rates will dampen borrowing. Treasuries modestly rebounded yesterday from last week's sell-off as weak global economic data and renewed equity market declines supported demand. Persistent inflation, rising oil prices tied to geopolitical conflict, and federal fiscal concerns pose continued risks to mortgage performance, though agency MBS prices were largely flat to open the week as markets remained focused on Fed commentary and tomorrow's FOMC minutes. Any meaningful rate relief will likely depend on easing geopolitical tensions, lower energy costs, and a less hawkish Federal Reserve. Fed officials, led by New York Fed President Williams, continued to emphasize that inflation remains too elevated and requires further policy action. A 25 basis point December hike is increasingly likely, with further tightening possible into early 2027. A 50-basis-point move lacks broader support. Although AI-driven productivity may eventually ease inflationary pressures, resilient growth and persistent price increases leave the Fed little incentive to pivot toward rate cuts or less restrictive monetary policy. Treasury markets are expected to remain volatile ahead of the December 4th jobs report and December 9th FOMC meeting, although safe haven demand, equity market uncertainty, and concerns over AI valuations could limit further yield increases and support a period of consolidation into early 2027. Put another way, treasury yields should remain elevated and the yield curve will be flatter until meaningful disinflation emerges. Today's economic calendar kicks off with October retail sales, expected to end at about 0.3%, and will be followed by October import and export prices, October industrial production and capacity utilization, September business inventories, remarks from Fed Governor Waller and New York Fed President Williams, and November's NAHB Housing Market Index. We began Tuesday with agency MBS prices, a little change from yesterday's close, the two-year yielding 4.81%, and the 10-year yielding 5.12% after closing yesterday at 5.12%. Let's wrap up with a joke and some housekeeping. What happens when you're too harsh on cranberries and make them sad? They turn into blueberries. What kind of cars would pilgrims drive today? Plymouth. Duh. Why did the Indians eat before the pilgrims? Because they had reservations. What kind of music do pilgrims The outside. Thanks again to Experian for sponsoring this week's podcasts. From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian.
Join 80,000+ mortgage professionals who start their day with Chrisman Commentary.
By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Chrisman LLC, 1930 Village Center Circle, #3-3932, Las Vegas, NV, 89134, https://www.chrismancommentary.com/. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact