← Nov 19 Thursday, November 19, 2026 Latest →
19
Thursday
November 2026
13 min read

The Housing Affordability Problem Is Not a Mortgage Finance Problem, It’s a Single-Family Home Problem

America’s housing affordability problem cannot be solved by the mortgage industry alone. Bipartisan housing policy, regulatory reform, and increased housing supply are needed, with cautious optimism out there that Washington can build on the ROAD to Housing Act. Bill Cosgrove of Union Home Mortgage takes a somewhat more sobering view: after 41 years in the business, he believes the industry must acknowledge there are no shortcuts to restoring affordability, and that trying to engineer one through mortgage products could create risks the industry has already learned the hard way.

In this conversation, Cosgrove examines the rapid expansion of non-QM lending, the fine line between alternative income documentation and a return to stated-income lending, and whether Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have become too conservative in areas where borrowers could be served responsibly. But his larger argument reaches beyond underwriting guidelines and product innovation. Housing affordability is fundamentally a real estate and supply problem, not a financing problem, and pushing lenders to stretch debt-to-income ratios or loosen documentation requirements will not create the homes Americans need. Rebuilding aging inner-city neighborhoods, encouraging more construction, and restoring a serious bipartisan conversation about housing will take years, not political slogans or another round of down payment assistance. Cosgrove isn’t pessimistic about homeownership; he’s arguing that the industry must be honest about what it can, and cannot, fix if it wants to avoid repeating the mistakes of 2005–2008.

Q: When we think about product expansion and evolution in mortgage banking, how has the industry changed, and what does the product landscape look like today compared with the past?

A: The more things change, the more they stay the same. Agency products are still very similar. Interest rates have been so low for so long that the traditional 30-year fixed-rate mortgage has remained the product of choice. For approximately 85 percent of customers in the country, you can’t argue with that. It’s pretty foolproof, and that consistency is what people need.

However, when you look at today’s non-QM products on the fringes, I think we have to ask ourselves as an industry how much of this is getting back to stated income. With DSCR and other non-QM products, if you pull back a couple of layers, how much of it is really getting back to stated income? I think we have to be cautious about that.

Q: We’re obviously not going back to the no-income, no-asset days. So, more specifically, where do you think things are slipping, and what potential warning signs should people be aware of?

A: I think it’s on the edges of documentation. If you have a borrower who isn’t a W-2 employee and is using a tax return, the old adage still applies: if the tax return doesn’t show the income, then how do you prove income?

Do you do it through bank statements? How many bank statements do you require? Do you require six to show a pattern? Do you require three? Do you get beaten down to two, one, or zero? Then you get a sign-off on a P&L from a tax accountant. How reliable is that?

If you go to a non-QM product and don’t have verified income through a tax return, pay stub, or W-2, and instead use a P&L verified by a tax accountant and one or two bank statements, how close are you really to stated income?

Q: How do you feel about the industry’s ability to assess risk today versus before AI? Advanced technology offers advantages in terms of time spent underwriting, but fraudsters can also become more sophisticated. How would you assess the industry’s overall ability to manage risk?

A: This is where Fannie, Freddie, and Ginnie come in, especially with the bifurcation of QM and non-QM. If you have documented income through pay stubs, W-2s, bank statements, and a tax return, then obviously the risk is very controlled. We’ve shown and proven that over decades.

Where we sometimes get ourselves into trouble is in the non-QM area we’re discussing now, whether it’s DSCR or another type of product. I think there’s a big market for it because many customers get paid in different ways that may or may not be reflected on a tax return, yet they have the financial ability to be homeowners.

How do you parse that? What documentation is required, and what isn’t waivable? I think it’s a fine line between acceptable risk and unacceptable risk.

Although non-QM has been around for a long time, it hasn’t really proliferated until the last four or five years. I think the jury is still out on the long-term level of risk that non-QM brings to the marketplace. Much of it will be fine, and there’s very limited risk in some non-QM products. But on some of the edges, if we continue eliminating income documentation, even when it’s nontraditional, we have to be careful that we don’t make a mistake when it comes to the risk associated with the outer edges of non-QM.

Q: Ginnie Mae has been gaining market share, and its share of MBS issuance is now above 40 percent. What does this shifting landscape, with Fannie and Freddie seemingly pulling back and Ginnie stepping in, mean for originators and for you in your position as CEO of a lender?

A: It doesn’t mean all that much. I think Fannie and Freddie need to look at their black box. They may be a little too conservative in some areas. I’m not a proponent of them getting into trouble like in the old days, but today they may be giving some market share to Ginnie, and perhaps a little to the non-QM world, in areas that could still represent very solid paper. I think that all needs to be considered.

Q: To clarify, you’re saying there are warning signs on the fringes of non-QM, but at the same time, Fannie and Freddie may be too conservative. What’s the proper middle ground?

A: On the Fannie and Freddie side, the higher-quality end of non-QM is where there’s an opportunity. Higher-level non-QM lending with more documentation, where income is truly verified, is an area where Fannie and Freddie could be a little more relaxed.

But on the opposite end of the spectrum, there are parts of the outer edges of non-QM that, if you pull back the curtain, look very close to stated income. That’s the part of non-QM where we have to be careful as an industry.

As business shrinks this time of year, with interest rates and the political environment, it’s important for us as an industry not to become aggressive on the very outer edges of non-QM.

Q: Affordability in this country is extremely challenging, yet the desire for homeownership remains strong. We want to put as many people into homes as possible, but we also want to do it responsibly. That doesn’t necessarily mean maximizing someone’s DTI to get them into a home. How do you reconcile the desire for homeownership with unaffordable housing costs and the industry’s development of new products to accommodate borrowers?

A: You’re right. I’ll say what a lot of people think but nobody wants to say: the affordability problem we have in America took a slow road of 20 years to develop, and it’s not going to be solved by a political gimmick. It’s not going to be solved by down payment assistance. There are a hundred different programs, but none of them solves the problem.

The only thing that solves it is time, a lot of time, because at the end of the day, we need more homes to be built.

There is a backlog of homes right now, and inventories are higher than they’ve been, but we have to keep pushing. I think fixing this requires some type of government-private partnership to rebuild the inner cities.

I’ve been doing this for 41 years, and I started my career financing post-World War II housing that was built in the 1950s. When I started financing those homes in the 1980s, they were only 30 years old. We’ve now got a massive amount of housing built between 1945 and 1975 in inner cities and first-ring suburbs. There are neighborhoods that need to be bulldozed and rebuilt, and that needs to happen.

Without that, you can only push development farther outward, which exacerbates the cost of building. We have to start building inward again.

Over time, simply looking at incomes versus what people qualify for, I think there will be very limited equity growth over the foreseeable future. Over the next five to 10 years, the stock market may outperform housing in terms of equity or return on equity because home prices will have to stagnate.

The combination of more inventory, more middle-class and upper-middle-class housing, and rebuilding cities over a decade may eventually allow us to address affordability.

But I’ll go on record: there is nothing that’s going to solve the affordability issue in the next five to seven years in this country. It’s not going to happen, and we need to come to that realization.

Q: I was going to ask whether you think there’s innovation within the mortgage industry that can help address this, but you’re saying it’s not really a mortgage industry issue.

A: It’s not a mortgage issue. If we make it a mortgage issue, we’re going to get back to 2005, 2008, and 2009, and we’re going to start doing things we shouldn’t do. We have to stay away from that. We can’t get back into that trouble.

In my 41-year career, we’ve only screwed it up once as an industry, and I have no desire for us to repeat that.

Affordability is not a mortgage issue to solve. It’s a housing issue, a housing market issue, and a real estate issue in America.

Q: Can advocacy with my congressman help? Is there something I should be doing differently or pushing for?

A: I think it starts with honesty. Some of what I’m saying, nobody wants to say because it doesn’t resonate politically. It doesn’t push the political buttons on either side of the aisle.

If I’m running for Congress, nobody has the conversation you and I are having: that it’s not a mortgage issue or a finance issue; it’s a real estate issue. It took 15 to 20 years for this problem to develop, and it’s not easily solvable. That doesn’t win elections.

But I think it starts with open, honest conversations. It’s not a mortgage finance issue. We can’t solve it. It’s a housing issue, a housing-in-America issue.

When I started in this business, Democrats and Republicans fought and called each other names, but when it came to housing, they almost became adults. There was a real housing conversation and strategy in this country. There was debate, and then there was action between Republicans and Democrats.

Unfortunately, over the last 10 to 12 years, housing in America has become part of the political fighting and ugliness of politics. This is my opinion, but there’s no longer an adult housing conversation happening in this country, and I think that’s contributed to the affordability issues we have today.

Q: I’ll take the optimistic side. With a divided government after the midterms, housing seems like an easy bipartisan win. Home affordability is a bipartisan issue. It’s something politicians could find an easy win on. I’m personally optimistic about a ROAD 2.0 or something similar that would allow elected representatives to say, “Here’s something I did for my constituency.”

A: The housing market in the United States is so big, and it really comes down to income versus housing costs versus household expenses. At the end of the day, with the average price of a home, there’s not much that can be done easily.

I think a divided Congress helps, but my real feeling is that where we are today with housing costs and how expensive the median home has become, there’s no easy fix.

It’s going to take adults, like in the old days. It’s really going to take Republicans and Democrats getting together, putting aside their differences on many issues, and recognizing that housing is the most important byproduct of this country. It’s the backbone of this country.

Let’s get in a room and try to figure it out.

One of the things people tried was to say, “Why don’t we just continue building rental housing? That will solve it.” But there’s been so much rental housing built, and that hasn’t solved the problem.

Everybody tries to solve affordability around the edges, but truly solving it is going to take a long time. That’s what nobody wants to acknowledge.

Q: Let’s end on a positive note. To be in the mortgage industry, we have to be eternal optimists. What gives you reasons for optimism, positivity, and the motivation to keep getting out of bed and moving forward every day?

A: When it comes to being positive, I think that if we, as a country and a government, actually start having the real conversation—not the political scorekeeping conversation about how housing can be used to score political points—that’s what I advocate for. We need to have real conversations with housing experts. If that happens, I think that’s a real positive.

I don’t feel I’m being negative. I really believe that speaking about the reality of the market and what we need to do to address those realities is positive.

That being said, I think we all recognize that there’s nothing wrong with rental housing, but building more rental housing doesn’t solve the affordability issue. I think we’re learning that, and that’s a positive.

Over the last 20 years since the crisis, Fannie, Freddie, and Ginnie have performed well. Politically, people try to either eliminate them or push their own agendas, but at the end of the day, the system works and provides capital. I think that’s good. We have to get away from politicizing Fannie, Freddie, and Ginnie.

And over the decades, homeownership, done right and affordably, is still the best way for an American family to build wealth over the long haul. I think housing has stood the test of time through all environments, and there’s a lot to be positive about.

We’re also slowly starting to address affordability through additional homebuilding.

Q: It’s always good to have tough conversations when the goal is to get to a better outcome in the future.

A: Right. 

Q: I really appreciate the time. As always, thank you.

A: You got it.

Bill Cosgrove, Owner & CEO, Union Home Mortgage

Get the Commentary

80,000+ mortgage professionals get this every weekday morning.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Chrisman LLC, 1930 Village Center Circle, #3-3932, Las Vegas, NV, 89134, https://www.chrismancommentary.com/. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact